Home Menu Search

Fatigue Management important for fleets

2 April 2020

A widely reported case has led to renewed call for fleets to adopt fatigue management policies after Renown Consultants is found guilty of health and safety breaches.

Renown Consultants was found guilty of breaches of the Health and Safety at Work Act in relation to the deaths of two drivers it employed at Nottingham Crown Court , last week.

Zac Payne, 20, and Michael Morris, 48, died following a crash at around 5.30am on June 19, 2013, when Payne fell asleep at the wheel of a company van while driving back to his employer’s Doncaster depot after a night shift in Stevenage.

The vehicle veered off the motorway, crashing into a parked van. He had been on the road since the 4.30am the previous morning, when he had driven to Alnmouth, Northumberland, to carry out welding work which didn’t materialise.s

During the return journey to Doncaster, he was allocated a further job in Stevenage and, collecting Morris to help, set off from the depot at 7.18pm before arriving at the site at 9.47pm. Both men started the work at 11.15 pm, completing it at 3.40am before heading back to Doncaster.

The Office of Rail and Road (ORR) told the court that Payne was suffering the effects of fatigue and may have fallen asleep at the wheel or experienced what were described as “microsleeps”.

 In its report Fleet News quotes Paul Hollick, co-chair of the Association of Fleet Professionals as saying: “This is the first prosecution for van driver fatigue of which we are aware and it is a very worrying case. 

“There was a complete breakdown of fleet management health and safety. The driver had been at work for more than 24 hours, creating a hugely risky situation that should never have occurred.”

Advice to managers on how to manage driver fatigue is available on the new Resources Section of the Driving for Better Business web site.

Transport and driver fatigue is a particularly common cause of work-related road traffic collisions resulting in injury or death.

The Road Safety Observatory offers information concerning driver fatigue on its comprehensive website which provides easy access to the best independent road safety research.

Fatigue accounts for up to one fifth of accidents on major roads, yet many people do not see this as a serious problem.

Related news, events and information

Employers Liability Bites

2 October 2007 – A kitchen-fitting employer was recently held liable for the injuries caused when his van driver fell asleep at...

Fleets get vehicle maintenance warning after death crash jailing

13 December 2009 – Drivers are ignoring vehicle maintenance warning signs - particularly in relation to tyre and brake wear - that...

Lcvs: Hours warning after death crash

1 August 2006 – A warning to companies that they must start tracking the working hours of their drivers is being issued to van...

Tired drivers can be as dangerous as drunk drivers

16 November 2007 – What Car? has shown that driving while you're tired can be as dangerous as drink driving. 40% of drivers admit...

Business drivers: don’t wing it with energy drinks

13 October 2009 – High mileage business drivers who use high energy drinks to keep them going have been warned by leading...

Workplace Transport Deaths and Injuries Rising

25 March 2008 – Norwich Union Risk Services (NURS) claim that workplace transport deaths and injuries are rising because...

Six million motorists almost fell asleep at the wheel last year

8 July 2009 – More than six million (13%) British motorists narrowly escaped adding to the thousands of fatigue-related road...

Scary stats about sleepy drivers

16 May 2013 – Business Champion ALD Automotive reports that an insurance industry survey of over 2,500 drivers, suggests that...

Bus driver fatigue management to become a London priority

9 September 2019 – Following the commissioning of research into bus driver fatigue Transport for London has mandated that from...