Home Menu Search

Fleet chiefs struggle to obtain ‘grey’ fleet driver legal compliance

15 October 2009

The majority of fleet managers are facing resistance from ‘grey’ fleet drivers when they want to carry out important safety and document checks, according to a survey by industry fortnightly Fleet News.

Checking ‘grey’ fleet vehicles are roadworthy and have valid MoT certificates is essential to guard against potential prosecution under the Corporate Manslaughter and Manslaughter Act or health and safety legislation and other laws impacting on at-work driving.

However, 71% of respondents to a Fleet News poll said that they were struggling to get their ‘grey’ fleet drivers to comply with their requests.

“A lot of the resistance is due to ‘grey’ fleet drivers not grasping how they can be legally affected by their responses or lack of them,” said Terry Fleury, fleetcom manager at Care Nursing.

Faced with such opposition, key to driver compliance was explaining the potential consequences of ignoring such requests, he said. But, the main reason behind fleet managers facing such resistance is the “the age old problem of ‘it’s not your car it’s mine’”, according to Ann Dukanovic, fleet manager at Kaba Door Systems.

“I merely state that we are contract hiring it from them for business use as opposed to from a lease company and as the fleet manager I have the right to ensure the vehicle is maintained, and run in a safe and legal manner,” said Ms Dukanovic. “It takes five minutes to sink in then they understand.”

The fact that fleet managers are facing opposition from their ‘grey’ fleet drivers comes in the wake of a Fleet News exclusive revealing more than 140,000 grey fleet drivers at 30 county councils were not having their vehicles inspected for safety.

However, this was due to the failings of public sector bosses for not instigating the legally required checks, rather than the resistance of ‘grey’ fleet drivers.

Nevertheless, the consequences of not managing employees who drive their own vehicles for work remain the same.

“Health and safety legislation says that employers must assess risks to their workforce and those affected by their activities and take steps to deal with those risks,” said a Department for Transport spokesman. “Driving at work needs to be treated in the same way as other work activities – ownership of a vehicle is irrelevant.”

Related news, events and information

Local union officials stand in way of public sector safe driving focus

9 December 2009 – Demand from local authorities for help in managing their at-work drivers is rising but resistance is being met...


16 June 2008 – Employees driving their own cars on business are a potential health and safety timebomb for employers, says...

Tyres top fleet safety agenda

22 February 2008 – Companies are introducing compulsory tyre safety checks to their fleets in record numbers amid concerns at the...

Grey Fleet Review

30 November 2018 – Driving for Better Business has just launched its new Grey Fleet Review, looking at the 14 million private...

Motorway crash broken neck victim uses experience to transform employer into road safety fleet champion

23 February 2010 – Suffering a broken neck in a road crash has given fleet manager Leigh Stiff a unique insight into why all...

Grey fleet mismanagement costing millions

17 October 2008 – A best practice guide for public sector bodies has warned that grey fleets could be wasting millions of pounds...

Police chief warns fleet operators

29 May 2012 – Story from Fleet News Fleet operators have been warned that police forces across the UK are waiting to convict...

Invalid grey fleet insurance warning

24 October 2023 – One in five grey fleet checks fail, with nine in 10 of these failures due to lack of appropriate insurance...


1 May 2008 – Safety-focused Kwik-Fit Fleet, Britain's largest independent fast-fit company, is launching a major...